Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jane Wilding's avatar

Thanks goodness it’s not actually a choice between Star Trek and Mad Max.

Democracy Defender's avatar

As a history teacher and a progressive I have studied and believed in utopian visions for most of my life. I'm very skeptical, but here are my thoughts if it is to be.

1. There is a book titled Bullshit Jobs. What's not a bullshit job? Your plumber, the trash collector, the nurse, the person cleaning the elderly and their bedpan in nursing homes. I don't think the real jobs will be taken over by robots, nor should they. Do you really want a robot caring for the dying? Do you want your child interacting just with a chatbot at school or a human being? The people working in nursing homes benefit our society so much more than the multi-millionaire athletes and celebs, but the people doing this caring work for the elderly get paid crap. AI is going to wipe out white collar first. I think there will be an oversupply of available labor despite declining populations in developed countries, but these white collar workers won't want to collect garbage or comfort the elderly in nursing homes.

2. AI needs to be taxed. It could be used for UBI, but before doing that, I think the funds should be used for expenses that we all worry about and could be provided by the government. These are: education, from daycare to graduate studies, free for all; healthcare, from birth to death; retirement and eldercare under a new system rather than the sterilized, soul crushing, fluorescent lighting of an institution. After these fundamental expenses, an AI tax could be used to build public competition as Corbin has been advocating, though I would create public banks to help fund this before tapping AI. If there is money left over, UBI.

3. Real jobs are going to need workers, and everyone is going to need to earn a little cash. The real jobs need to pay a lot better, and the average work week needs to be very short so everyone (who is willing to do the real work) has the opportunity to earn an income for their needs not covered above.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?